Health Articles

Recognising the human capacity to adopt and sustain new behaviours in change programmes

Change has become a business-as-usual feature of working life for many employees. A recent McKinsey report showed that in 2016, organisations had on average two change projects. Now, ten years later, an average organisation has ten planned change projects per year. As leaders and board directors strive to keep businesses competitive, with continuous growth and long-term profitability, a lot of change programmes are overseeing the complexity of human capital that is crucial for change adoption and sustainable performance.

Research by HR Director (November 2025) provides a revealing picture of the consequences. 39% of UK employees reported feeling more stressed at work because of change programmes, while one in four considered leaving their job because of the volume of change. Additionally, 44% of respondents identified increased workloads and pressure as their principal concern for continuing being productive and delivering on their role responsibilities.

New technologies, AI adoption, organisational restructuring, operating-model redesign and shifting commercial priorities increasingly begin to overlap, requiring people to adapt while continuing to deliver against existing performance expectations. Despite decades of research demonstrating that sustainable organisational change depends on changes in human behaviour, many transformation programmes still prioritise the implementation of new systems, structures and processes, assuming that employees will adapt accordingly.

This raises a fundamental question for executive boards: are the people responsible for change programmes deliver them with a ‘re-packaged’ project management strategy, or are they really thinking about human capacity for behaviour change during change design, delivery and sustenance?

When transformation programmes succeed, technology and processes get the credit. But when they fail, people and organisational culture often get the blame. Indeed, technology and processes are easier to quantify, measure the rate and speed of adoption; they are visible, offer clarity and don’t respond with resistance or talk-back. Human decisions involve ambiguity, uncertainty, emotional management, continuous feedback, tweaking and readjusting the course. This demands sustained attention, and it demands leaders to be equipped with the skills specific to change management.

Change management and project management differences

Project management and change management have a lot of overlap, both are concerned with processes, technology and people. However, the differences are crucial in the success of change management. Project management is concerned with the speed of adoption, integration and sustainability of new technology and systems, while the cornerstone of change management is human capital - the capability of people to adopt systems and processes to their desired outcomes. The success of change is largely dependent on the leadership capability to get involved, to listen and to motivate their staff; to stay fully present during the delivery phase and to care about any roadblocks, challenges and risks that may arise on the path of successful change. It is therefore not simply a delivery process, but a testament to leadership.

Many organisations invest a lot of resources and energy into the technology and processes aspects of change, but allocate a fraction of their energy to the human experience. The CEB workforce survey (“Open Source Change”, 2016) showed that 50% of leaders don’t know whether recent change initiatives in their organisation were successful or not; and 51% of managers and employees say their leaders do not outline clear success metrics for change.

The interesting aspect of that survey, in over 6,600 employees studied, 64% of respondents said they had most skills ready for change (such as acting on one’s initiative, thinking strategically, producing creative solutions, absorbing and understanding new information, being supportive of others); and 74% of employees say they were willing to change in order to support organisational change. Despite their capabilities and willingness to change, the survey found that most employees do not effectively implement change. Only 26% of employees agreed that they effectively changed how they work to support a recent change programme.

Human consequences of change - change fatigue, underperformance, rework and errors - are often treated as a separate HR responsibility, instead of being an integral part of transformation design, delivery and success measures. But implementing a new system is not the same as changing human behaviour. As this aspect of change success becomes too difficult for measure, many leaders do not give it enough attention. For change behaviour to happen, which can be sustained long-term, we need to connect the change to the future outcomes that are aligned with our own values, belief systems, as well as being built around our strengths and capacities. Otherwise, organisational systems and processes may change, but the intended operational and financial benefits of transformation may never be fully realised.

Activating behaviour change in change programmes

The human ability to change behaviour depends on both the external and internal (or “autonomous”, Deci & Ryan’s work) motivational factors. External regulation occurs when someone other than ourselves, such as a manager, spouse, parent or close friend tells us what to do, which instigates behaviour of “I will do what this person wants me to do to avoid conflict”. External motivation also happens when we internalise the external ideal, without deeper alignment with personal values and desires, such as seen in the behaviour patterns of “I should”, “I ought”. People will say things such as “I know I should collaborate with my team colleagues” due to the expectations of their team leader and as part of their role description. However, this will be the extend of their exploration of behaviour and reflection. The changes in behaviour may occur, due to external motivating factors, but they are not sustainable long-term.

Internal motivation, or “autonomous”, conversely, is centred on the beliefs, values, capabilities and strengths of the person. People are motivated to change because the change in behaviour connects to something in the future that they value. When people have internalised the reasons to do something different to how things have been done before because it is good for their future, or fits with the set of values they aspire to, then the change in behaviour can be sustained long-term.
One more aspect of autonomous motivation happens when people are truly engaged and love to do an activity that makes them experience the flow - often seen in people playing sports or music, programmers writing new code, or marketing teams collaborating on a new campaign. When the activity taps into people’s strengths, when they experience engagement and fun, they are more willing to give it their best focus and effort.

For a change manager, it is easy to assume that their own intrinsic desire to support a change, based on the set of objectives - the knowledge of what needs to change - is inherent in other people and enough to instigate change in behaviour. Due to the false consensus effect - a cognitive bias, by which people overestimate how much others share their opinions, patterns of thinking and beliefs, change managers often wrongly assume that if their own awareness of the need for change made them want to change, then it will have the same effect on others. Instead, the desire for change in individuals is based around these factors:

  • The actual nature of change
  • The organisational context for the change
  • The employee’s personal situation
  • What motivates them as individuals

In the environments where change happens nearly continuously, with pressure from executive board and shareholders, change leaders are conditioned to demonstrate adoption quickly. In many scenarios, change initiative will be a top-down approach, with announcements made by the executive team, roadmaps published, and delivery will be scheduled and launched before the organisation, and most importantly, individuals, have had time to understand the intent behind them and also digest what the current change could mean for them personally. Jeff Hiatt, the creator of the Prosci ADKAR Model, warns against moving on to the Knowledge part of change strategy before adequate Awareness and Desire have been created and assessed. Involving people at the beginning of change, in the design part, creating in a two-way communication early on, have demonstrated that success rate of change is 38% higher in those organisations with well-executed change communication plan.

Communicating change effectively

According to People Alliance, leaders who treat change initiatives as a project that needs to be delivered instead of a human experience that needs to be supported, consistently underperform. Most effective leaders resist that impulse. They recognise that change creates a strong emotional and cognitive toll before it can produce organisational results. Involving people from the start of change design makes a strong foundation to the future engagement, motivation, commitment and effort in change delivery. Human behaviour is complex: so much of our individual response depends on our external circumstances, as well as health, relationships, peer support, organisational status and the motivation factors I spoke of before. If emotional and cognitive load of change is not acknowledged and properly managed, employees will follow instructions, but they will not internalise change, they may comply but not commit. Therefore, adoption may be slow, superficial, with a high rate of technical errors or rework, deadlines pushed forward, and progress may stall.

When this happens, the workforce-related outcomes, such as employee retention, low engagement, decreased motivation, stress absence and personal goal accomplishment will be pushed through HR and People functions. While executive leaders may protect their priorities of change, such as improved productivity, new product line, adoption of technology, improved competitive advantage, sustainable growth, for HR and People Directors the challenge will also include maintenance of workforce capability, retention of experienced employees, managing absence and ensuring the organisation has the skills and capacity to deliver.

These should not be compartmentalised, these are not competing agendas. They are different measures of the same organisational capability: the ability to change while sustaining performance.

Involving people earlier, during change design

In their research on change strategy, Michael Beer and Russell Eisenstat identified several organisational barriers that can prevent otherwise sound strategies from being translated into effective action. Factors, such as weak communication between teams and organisational levels, poor cross-functional coordination, conflicting priorities, workload and poor leadership capability are among those where most mistakes were made.

Research by Shaul Oreg, Maria Vakola and Achilles Armenakis demonstrates that employees' responses to change depend on the organisational context, the change process itself and the consequences people expect to experience. However, leaders often make the mistake of moving with the “how” instead of engaging more people in the “why” processes. The rationale seems to be clear: announcing the need for change, explaining the strategy and progressing with the detailed plan for execution will ensure to give people a good direction of what is expected of them. But the findings from Oreg’s research challenge a persistent assumption: once a new structure has been approved, a system introduced and employees trained, the required behavioural change may not naturally follow, as people create resistance or revert to old behaviours.

People may learn how to operate a new system within weeks. However, to establish new habits, change decision-making patterns and create collaborative behaviours in the environment of changing roles and responsibilities, requires an entirely different approach. It requires building early engagement, creating a rapport of trust and understanding between leadership, middle management and front line delivering change; it requires building new supportive working conditions and assessments of current and future capacity that can stimulate practising unfamiliar behaviours until they become established.

It also requires something completely different from the usual KPIs: creating a personal connection to the organisational values. People are more likely to change behaviours when they understand their purpose, believe they have the capability to perform them and experience sufficient autonomy and support in doing so. Self-determination theory (SDT), by Deci and Richard Ryan, identifies autonomy, competence and relatedness as fundamental psychological needs supporting the quality and sustainability of behavioural motivation.

This is where assessing readiness for change and awareness building are not simply smart communication messages from change leadership team to the workforce. Assessing individual readiness for change can prevent a lot of challenges that arise in the delivery phase. Change leaders need to include the following factors when building awareness:

  • Individuals’ view of the current state. Questions to ask: Are they happy with what they do and see their daily work contributing to the organisational growth? Are they dissatisfied, frustrated with their responsibilities and may see the need for change more acutely? Are they ambivalent of what their current work is contributing to the organisational goals?

  • How do they perceive current problems? Do they feel psychologically safe to express their concerns and provide feedback without the fear or retribution?

  • Help people identify their needs that can connect with new behaviour, not strategies for behaviour adoption. Needs represent our values, wants, desires and preferences for a happier and more meaningful experience as a human. According to Marshall Rosenberg and his NVC model, even though humans have different needs in differing amount at different times, the needs are universal to all of us, such as “the need for competence, connection, safety, support and love”. Identifying individuals’ needs help not only get people on board earlier, but also support them in the forthcoming emotional turmoil, as they get challenged by competing projects, confusing messages, increased workload, roles’ changes, cognitive fatigue and capacity demands.

  • What is their perception of the reasons for change? Do they understand the current challenges within the company, in the marketplace?

Use smart behaviour assessment tools

Although assessments are valuable when used appropriately, supported and within the framework of leadership coaching, there’s a danger to use assessments as a tick-box exercise without properly incorporating the results’ values into the change strategy.

Assessments might be completed when people are taxed from their daily responsibilities, or distracted, they may do them at the last minute, or make responses that impress or please their manager. Hence, assessments are not always accurate and don’t tell the whole story.

Assessments can be a useful tool to uncover the motivational drivers of behaviour, as well as the most important aspects of one’s individual circumstances and priorities of work.

Here are a few worth considering:

  1. Health risk appraisal - developed by Dee Edington, PhD, - health promotion researcher. The Edington tool looks at a variety of wellbeing components important for individuals that can impact their work and adoption of change. Adapting this to the workplace, individuals can be assessed on these parameters:

  • Energy: levels of energy throughout a typical day
  • Life satisfaction: sense of purpose, work satisfaction, joy, personal relationship satisfaction
  • Mental and emotional fitness: coping skills, resilience, stress levels, emotional status, social support.

2. Readiness, willingness and confidence rulers - taken from motivational interviewing practice (MI), these assessment tools help identify how important it is for individuals to change their behaviour, assessing their willingness for change, readiness for change and confidence in the goals’ achievement. The willingness scale may additionally help highlight competing priorities, as it gauges if the change is as important as everything else going on.

3. Self-efficacy assessment: Social Cognitive Theory (by A. Bandura) - is a resource to understand the factors that influence individuals for building self-efficacy of behaviour to be sustained long-term. SCT asserts that human behaviour is conditioned by the three factors that interact with each other: 1. personal factors - what one believes and how one feels about what one can do, i.e. their capacity; 2. environmental factors - the quality of support networks and role models one has; 3. behavioural factors - what one experiences on the daily basis and their individual accomplishments. SCT emphasises that our cognitive processes are central to constructing our reality and relating behaviour.

Create conversation instead of ‘telling' what needs to be done

One of the common mistakes change leaders make is building their communications strategy of the “telling” style. There are multiple drawbacks that can arise from this style of communication.

  • Interpreting the message: the same message gets interpreted differently by individuals.
  • The contradiction in perception: the sender of the message is not the same person the audience expects to hear that message from.
  • People expect executive leaders to deliver the ‘why' the change is happening, however, they prefer their direct managers to explain the specifics of ‘what’ change will mean to them individually.
  • Sending the message does not mean it will be read.
  • Written communication does not include tone and body language, which are important for effective communication.
  • Confusion and misunderstanding, rumours - cannot be addressed in this style of communication.

Instead, a well-structured communications plan needs to include employees early on, involving them in the change design, by entrusting them with the responsibility to co-create the new reality - after all, they are the experts that make stuff happen daily. Gaining their input from surveys, focus groups, panel discussions, focusing on building a dialogue, with an ultimate aim to connect the people involved in the organisational daily operation with the executives planning the change project. Thus, conversations need to happen not vertically, but in a complex matrices style, up - down, left - right, in all sorts of direction. Successful change strategies have seen companies do a 48-hours with the CEO, who having collected employees emails created an online Q&A session answering employees’ concerns; leaders walking the floor, spontaneously stopping to discuss with employees their concerns and fears; ideas boxes - visible throughout the whole company with employees encouraged to drop their messages for the leadership team to read, and other.

Importantly, the two-way communication style needs to be built on the rapport of mutual trust, acceptance and transparency. Often times, leaders who are not trained in change management, having checked on the delivery of the change project, move on to the new ‘hot spots’ abandoning the current change half-way through. This can erode employees’ confidence, decrease motivation and commitment and can stall progress.

It is therefore important to build a structured communications plan that has a detailed map of the audiences, methods and channels of communications, media formats, includes the people involved in communications delivery, as well as frequency that is build through all the phases - change design, delivery and evaluation process.

When is a change genuinely complete? Measuring results

A digital transformation programme may report that 95% of employees have completed training, and that the new platform has been successfully launched. A restructuring may achieve its planned implementation date, and a new operating model may be formally adopted across departments.

These are successful implementation indicators. But they do not necessarily tell us whether the organisation is working more effectively six, twelve or eighteen months later. Are employees consistently using the new processes, or gradually returning to familiar workarounds? Has the new system reduced administrative effort, or simply redistributed it? Are managers making better decisions, or spending more time resolving problems created by the transition?

A programme can be delivered on time without its intended behaviours becoming permanent. Research by Prosci shows the importance of reinforcement of change. Their evidence demonstrates that 81% of projects where reinforcement was planned met or exceeded objectives, compared with 15% where it was not planned.

The question is whether organisations continue measuring adoption and operational performance after the transformation team has moved on to the next project.

The early metrics of change success may be relatively difficult to identify in financial reports.

Harold Sirkin and colleagues offered an important perspective in their DICE framework for assessing change implementation. Alongside project duration, implementation-team capability and leadership commitment, they explicitly included the additional effort required from employees.

This is particularly relevant to organisations where change has become business as usual. Every new system, operating model or organisational structure requires additional attention, learning, engagement and behavioural change. Rating the elements of the DICE model at regular evaluation intervals allows change teams assess where tweaks or needed, or more resources need to be allocated, and most importantly, if the commitment of both sponsors and senior leaders as well as middle management is there to support the sustainability of change.

During these review sessions, it could be beneficial to include an integrated assessment of human performance risk: the behavioural, cognitive, physiological and organisational conditions that influence whether employees can sustain effective performance while adapting to change.

This means examining engagement and training completion together with individuals’ workload, cognitive demands, available learning time, energy management and recovery, as well as the supporting conditions required to reinforce new behaviours.

It could also mean connecting these earlier indicators with the commercial measures already important to executive boards: productivity, rework, retention of key talent, operational capacity, service quality and sustainable financial performance.

The objective is not to transfer responsibility from transformation teams to HR, or vice versa. It is to establish shared accountability for the workforce capability required to deliver organisational objectives.

Measuring success

Alongside project milestones and financial outcomes, organisations could measure time to proficiency, sustained use of new processes, avoidable rework, workload pressure, decision delays, employee retention and relevant absence trends, connecting achieved milestones with individual performance goals.

A need to assess behavioural adoption and human performance is also key at several stages: before implementation, during transition, at the point of delivery and then at six, twelve and eighteen months post-adoption.

In the CEB survey, 51% of managers and employees said their leaders do not regularly outline clear success metrics for change.

The top indicators of change success that organisations could use are:

  • Completion of change objectives
  • Positive employee attitudes about change and alignment of personal goals with organisational objectives
  • Consistent implementation of changes

These indicators should not be interpreted in isolation. They need to be assessed alongside operational demand, staff changes and other factors that can influence performance. But together they could provide a much earlier understanding of whether the organisation is building sustainable performance while strengthening its workforce capability.

There is also an important role for behavioural science, psychology, physiology and neuroscience in understanding how sustained mental demands, fatigue, recovery, anxiety and stress impacts, as well as established habits affect the ability to sustain change. These disciplines can contribute practical insights into change design, leadership development and workforce performance, provided interventions are evidence-based and evaluated against measurable outcomes.

The real test of change projects is not solely whether people have adopted a new system. It is whether the organisation can sustain the intended improvements while navigating continuous change.


Resources:

1. Investors in People (2025), HR Director, 2025.

2. Oreg, S., Vakola, M. and Armenakis, A. (2011). Change Recipients' Reactions to Organizational Change: A 60-Year Review of Quantitative Studies. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science.

3. Beer, M. and Eisenstat, R. A. (2000), MIT Sloan Management Review: https://shop.sloanreview.mit.edu/store/the-silent-killers-of-strategy-implementation-and-learning?utm_source=chatgpt.com

4. Sirkin, H. L., Keenan, P. and Jackson, A. (2005), Harvard Business Review: https://hbr.org/2005/10/the-hard-side-of-change-management?utm_source=chatgpt.com

5. Change management in HR: strategies, challenges, & real-world examples, People Alliance: https://www.peoplealliance.com/articles/change-management-in-hr/

6. Open Source Change: Making Change Management Work, CEB survey, 2016

7. Underperformance Process, People Alliance

8. ADKAR: A model for change in business, government and our community, Jeffery M. Hiatt, 2006

9. Coaching Psychology Manual, Margaret Moore, Erika Jackson, Bob Tschannen-Moran, second edition, 2016

5. Prosci, Reinforcement and Sustaining Change Management: https://www.prosci.com/blog/reinforce-and-sustain-change?utm_source=chatgpt.com